Abstract
We evaluated the efficacy of different neutralizing solutions for use in disinfectant efficacy assays. Our approach used comparisons between the recoveries of low inocula in different treatment populations. The challenge organisms employed were those described by the AOAC for use in determining germicidal, tuberculocidal, sporicidal, and fungicidal activity of disinfectants. Neutralizer efficacy (NE) ratios were determined by comparing the recovery of identical inocula from the neutralizing solution in the presence, or the absence, of a 1:10 dilution of the biocide. Neutralizer toxicity (NT) ratios were determined between recovery of viable microorganisms incubated for a short period in peptone, and in the neutralizing medium without the biocide. An effective and non-toxic neutralizer was initially identified by NE and NT ratios of ≥ 0.75. Statistical evaluation of the data was performed by ANOVA, with Dunnett's test for multiple comparisons used to confirm failures. By this analysis, 239/244 identified failures were confirmed by ANOVA of 588 NT and NE comparisons (5 presumptive failures were not confirmed by statistical analysis). We therefore conclude that recovery of 75% is a suitable criterion (2% false negative rate) for neutralizer evaluations. There was a wide degree of variability seen among the responses of different test organisms to the different recovery broths. Pseudomonas aeruginosa and Salmonella choleraesuis were particularly sensitive to commercial neutralizer broths. Interestingly, no commercially available neutralizer proved adequate for all index organisms against all biocides tested. This finding underscores the need to evaluate potential neutralizers against all microorganisms and biocides employed.
Footnotes
- Copyright © Parenteral Drug Association. All rights reserved.
PDA members receive access to all articles published in the current year and previous volume year. Institutional subscribers received access to all content. Log in below to receive access to this article if you are either of these.
If you are neither or you are a PDA member trying to access an article outside of your membership license, then you must purchase access to this article (below). If you do not have a username or password for JPST, you will be required to create an account prior to purchasing.
Full issue PDFs are for PDA members only.
Note to pda.org users
The PDA and PDA bookstore websites (www.pda.org and www.pda.org/bookstore) are separate websites from the PDA JPST website. When you first join PDA, your initial UserID and Password are sent to HighWirePress to create your PDA JPST account. Subsequent UserrID and Password changes required at the PDA websites will not pass on to PDA JPST and vice versa. If you forget your PDA JPST UserID and/or Password, you can request help to retrieve UserID and reset Password below.