TABLE II

Summary of the Advantages and Limitations of All Tested Sensors

Sensor TypeAdvantageLimitation
Airflow
  • Contact-free measurement

  • Liquid independent

  • Very sensitive to venting airflow

  • Slow signal generation (indirect measurement)

  • Sensitive to environment

  • Long distance between the reservoir and the dispensing needle

Capacitive Pressure
  • Contact-free measurement

  • High accuracy and precision

  • Direct measurement of the pressure of the dispensed fluid

  • Troubleshooting analysis possible by specific pattern recognition

  • Susceptible to electromagnetic fields (shielding necessary)

  • Air bubbles strongly influence the signal

  • Distance between the point of measurement and the dispensing needle

MEMS
  • Well established technology

  • High accuracy and precision

  • Sensor in direct contact with the fluid

  • Air bubbles influence the measurement signal

  • Sensor material incompatible with medical standards

  • Distance between the point of measurement and the dispensing needle

Optical
  • Contact-free measurement

  • High accuracy and precision

  • Fast, analogue signal generation

  • Located at the orifice of the filling needle

  • Jet velocity information is not measured

  • Color, turbidity directly influence the signal

  • Different stray light conditions

  • Quantification of results rather complex

Capacitive
  • Contact-free measurement

  • High accuracy and precision

  • Fast, analogue signal generation

  • Located at the orifice of the filling needle

  • Independent of fluid properties like viscosity, color, turbidity

  • Jet velocity information is not measured

  • Wetting of the sensor electrodes might imply cross-contamination

  • Permittivity of the fluid influences the signal