TABLE II

Operation Qualification Test Results

ProcedureExpected ResultsResults As Expected (Yes/No)
SOP ListThe draft version of SOP for operation and maintenance was available. The SOP number, title, revision number, and date issued were documented in the protocol.Yes
OBSERVA® Software Security Level VerificationAll the predefined access levels and password expiration times were verified. Each access level was verified for password security. Only the authorized users were allowed to access the system based on their access level.Yes
OBSERVA® Software Screen Navigation VerificationThe navigation of the OBSERVA® software was verified. he software allows a user to move from one screen to another.Yes
OBSERVA® Software ConfigurationAll the configuration including report template, shortcuts, data fields, screen views, date/time format, groups, and global report heading of the OBSERVA® software were verified.Yes
OBSERVA® Software Access Level VerificationAll the access levels defined in the protocol were verified. The system allows the user to access the privileges depending on the user's access level.Yes
BacT/ALERT Workstation Security VerificationThe BacT/ALERT workstation security setup functions were verified and found satisfactorily. Each user access level was verified for password security. Only the authorized users were allowed to access the system functions based on their access level.Yes
Barcode Scanner Verification at BacT/ALERT WorkstationAll the scanned information of the bottles matched with the actual information for unaltered bottle. The bottle ID was not able to be scanned for the altered bottle.Yes
BacT/ALERT Instrument Security VerificationThe password protection capabilities and access levels were verified. The system allowed only the authorized user to access the instrument based on the user's access level and only the administrator to add or delete the user. Only the administrator has access to configuration, adding, deleting, and editing functions.Yes
BacT/ALERT Instrument Alarm Verification TestThe open door alarm, high temperature alarm, and low temperature alarm function accurately.Yes
Power Loss/Equipment Failure TestThe incubator failure alarm, controller failure alarm, UPS failure, and communication failure between incubator and controller module alarm was verified and found satisfactorily.Yes
BacT/ALERT Instrument Screen Navigation VerificationThe navigation of the BacT/ALERT instrument was verified. The software allows moving from one screen to another.Yes
Barcode Scanner Verification at BacT/ALERT InstrumentAll the scanned information of the bottles matched with the actual information for unaltered bottle. The bottle ID was not able to be scanned for the altered bottle.Yes
System Function VerificationThe system function test was performed to verify the system functions and trigger the operator error and instrument error alarms. All the functions were successfully verified.Yes
Report Logged Temperature VerificationThe incubator chamber temperature was randomly read from the calibrated thermometer. All the data match with the report printed from the system.Yes
Enable/Disable Cells, Racks, Drawers VerificationThe enable/disable function for cells, racks, and drawers was verified. All the functions work satisfactorily.Yes
Data Backup VerificationThe manual backup and automatic backup were performed and verified with date and time on both instrument and computer system. The report generated was backed up to the network drive and retrieved from the network drive.Yes
Temperature Calibration VerificationThe system can accurately calibrate the temperature.Yes
Cell Calibration VerificationThe system can accurately calibrate the cells.Yes
Audit Trail VerificationThe audit trail report was printed from the instrument and computer system. The activities in the report accurately represent the activity performed.Yes
Archived Report VerificationThe archived report was accessible and cannot be edited.Yes
Empty Chamber Temperature Distribution StudyTwenty-two (22) thermocouples were distributed geometrically inside the chamber. The temperature was monitored continuously every 5 min for 24 h. All the temperatures recorded by the thermocouples remained within the required temperature range of 30–35 °C.Yes
Loaded Chamber Temperature Penetration StudyTo simulate the load condition, all the slots were filled with bottles with pre-filled media (60 bottles in each drawer). All the temperatures recorded by the thermocouples remained within the required temperature range of 30–35 °C.Yes