TABLE VIII

Presence of Transformation Triggers in Primary and Derived Articles and Relative Ranking

Reference	Source (See Notes)	Year	No. of Citations	Trigger 1	Trigger 2	Trigger 3	Trigger 4	Trigger 5	Trigger 6	Trigger 7	Trigger 8	Trigger 9	Trigger 10	Trigger 11	Trigger 12	Trigger 13	Trigger 14
1	Acd	2006	8					116
2	Acd	2004	4		42	82	40						37
3	Con	2005	2	33				27	24
4	Org	2007	3	13				12	11
5	Con	2009	0	58	55
6	Acd	2008	0		80
7	Gov	2004	30			14					127		126			125
8	Gov	2005	2							63	62
9	Gov	2009	0			108		97		94				88	86
10	Gov	2007	0			121					92		89			85
11	Acd	2008	47		146	142		138		137						133
12	Acd	2006	4			53		74		72							64
13	Acd	2009	18		145	39
14	Acd	2003	490		122	141
15	Acd	2009	3		81	119
16	Acd	2010	4														36
22	Con	2007	3	60	57				48
23	Con	2002	1		56											43
24	Acd	2009	7		123		117
25	Ind	2009	1		30			26
26	Org	2005	15	31	29			25
27	Acd	2007	10		124	99
28	Ind	2004	0			2
29	Con	2005	51	109		52									103
30	Acd	2009	2			54		76								68
31	Ind	2007	50	111		143
32	Acd	2009	8			98
33	Con	2006	4			144
34	Con	2008	0	59		78	50	49
35	Ind	2001	112			79		75
36	Ind	2006	11					107
37	Acd	2007	21			77
38	Ind	2006	7					73
40	Acd	2006	14					139
41	Con	2003	343														102
42	Ind	2001	19											105
43	Acd	2004	4														35
44	Acd	2005	10														101
45	Acd	2008	4														66
46	Acd	2003	21														113
47	Acd	2008	16														128
48	Acd	2005	24														110
49	Acd	2009	1														65
50	Acd	2008	9														112
51	Acd	2009	64														131
52	Con	2009	0														41
53	Acd	2009	1														67
54	Ind	2009	0	32												15
55	Ind	2008	0	34							20	18
56	Acd	2007	37				140										130
57	Con	2008	2	61			51					46				44
58	Org	1998	3				1
59	Acd	2008	4			120
60	Con	2006	0						47
61	Acd	2005	42													114
62	Con	2002	5						106
63	Con	2004	0						22		19
64	Acd	2009	1		83
65	Ind	2009	1							21
66	Org	2009	0							10
67	Org	2006	6		28				23
68	Gov	2006	0		100	118		96	95	93	91			87		84
69	Acd	2008	16								136
70	Ind	2008	5								71
71	Con	2008	0									45
72	Gov	2007	3									90
73	Acd	2007	3									69
74	Acd	2007	1									38
75	Acd	2008	0									70
76	Org	2009	0										9
77	Org	2009	0										8
78	Con	2001	21											104
79	Org	2000	35											17
80	Ind	2009	0											16
81	Acd	2001	83											115
82	Acd	2006	153												134
83	Org	2006	0												7		5
84	Acd	2007	36												135
85	Org	2009	1												6
86	Org	2005	0			129										4
87	Acd	2006	33													132
88	Org	2003	3														3
N	146		n	11	16	22	6	15	8	7	8	7	5	7	6	11	17
Sample size = 82	# of triggers K = 14		Rank	7	3	1	12	4	13	9	6	11	14	8	10	5	2

Notes: Numbers in trigger columns are the ranking values, which also are used as an indication if the transformation trigger was present in the associated article.
Acd, academic; Con, consulting; Gov, government; Ind, Industry; Org, research organization.